查看完整版本: IGN发出的PS3/360版本总结比较视频来了

IGN发出的PS3/360版本总结比较视频来了

首先请无视那位kotaku的编辑冒着生命危险写下的评语

[color=#ff0000]PS3版的画面咋看起来好像锯齿感更甚，[/color]但在零售版中仔细鉴别一番后，你会发现其实它们两个旗鼓相当。
[color=red]主观上360版似乎更顺滑，特定场景下拥有更高的帧率——比如遇到局促的空间或轻度拥堵[/color]，但两个版本在帧率起伏上都有相似的表现。

这种评语算是炫耀智商么？还是浪费大家的时间？

大家也可以去看看国外玩家是怎么嘲笑这位kotaku编辑的。
[url]http://www.n4g.com/NewsCom-139822.aspx?CT=1#Comments[/url]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


IGN Insider的工作人员特意制作的版本比较视频
[url=http://www.rockstarwatch.net/news/469/IGN-Compares-GTAIV-for-the-PS3-and-360/]http://www.rockstarwatch.net/news/469/IGN-Compares-GTAIV-for-the-PS3-and-360/[/url]

大致的结果：

首先，两个版本的无论是画面还是操作还是其他，都是非常的好的，两个主机的表现在各个项目的比较里都是同样的很优秀，所以即使比较得出的一些小差异，也根本不影响你的游戏经历。


画面方面

- PS3的抗锯齿略为优秀，比360版更加圆润光滑，当然这个基本要把两个电视摆一起才能明显感觉到

- 感谢了PS3版7分钟左右的硬盘强制安装，总体上的表现PS3版略强但是不影响游戏，比如说读取时间PS3版更快，但是快不过4秒钟以上

- 光线，对比度，色彩的区别也是有的，360版的色彩更加丰富，光线也更亮，不过游戏选项里的设置可以在这方面的调节极多，无论哪个版本哪种电视你都可以自己微调这些选项来达到满意的结果。

控制方面

- PS3版比360版多出了六轴操作，六轴可以用来操作交通工具，玩迷你游戏，以及给武器上弹等

- 直升飞机用六轴很美，船舶也OK，机车用六轴就很傻了；做疯狂特技跳时，车子在空中可以用六轴微调角度

- 飞镖和保龄可以用六轴

- 上下猛甩手柄是给武器上弹

- 摇杆操作上，PS3版的驾驶难度比较低，360版的车较难开

- 因为瞄准模式的转换是根据扳机强度来定的，360手柄的优秀扳机使操作更体贴，PS3版的扳机活动度差，不过GTA4既然要玩很久，多出来一段时间的手柄上手时间也不算什么

多人模式

- 因为本作的多人模式十分出色，使得这个也成了选择版本的因素之一，应该尽量选择你的朋友大多数选择的游戏版本，这样才可以一起玩MP
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
另付上各大媒体对2个版本的评价，几乎是一面倒的认为PS3版更出色

IGN (10 out of 10 for both versions)


Quote:
Past GTA titles have had mild-to-serious framerate issues and technical glitches, because the games were trying to do far more than the PlayStation 2 could handle. While GTA IV is pushing the PS3 and 360 to the limit, it also runs amazingly well. Sure, there are framerate hitches here and there and (particularly on 360) there is some texture pop-in, but it actually runs better than I expected. That a game with great AI, an awesome physics engine and a detailed open world runs so well and with such short load times is a technical marvel. For that, I can forgive framerate issues and some noticeable aliasing.

The art team gets major kudos for creating a living world. There is great texture work in the environments, a nice field-of-vision blur of buildings in the distance, some excellently modeled cars, ball-jarring explosions, phenomenal water effects and one interesting-looking Eastern Euro for a lead character. Sure, it's not a game that runs perfectly all the time, but the technical elements almost never get in the way of the gameplay.

For those wanting to know which version looks better, the edge goes to the PS3. The textures and framerate are comparable, but the PS3 has far less pop-in. The 360 has richer colors, but the PS3 has better anti-aliasing making it look a little cleaner. Because GTA IV can preload onto the PS3 hard drive, the in-game loads are faster. Don't worry Xbox owners, the load times are rarely more than 30 seconds and don't occur very often. The slight visual edge goes to PS3, but the 360 is no slouch. Either version will do you proud.


EGM (Print):


Quote:
Grand Theft Auto IV - A+, A+, A
Good: World, relationships, story
Bad: Some missions canned, control takes getting used to
PS3 or 360 version: 360 for DLC, PS3 version looks slightly more vibrant and sharp


1up.com (A+)


Quote:
None of these little flaws take away from Liberty City's breathtaking vistas, incredibly varied scenery, and lived-in look (the PS3 version has the slightest visual edge, plus motion-control support -- but then it's missing Achievements and the eventual downloadable episodes exclusive to the 360 game). The city just feels alive.


GamesRadar


Quote:
While the PS3 and 360 versions of the game are functionally identical, the PS3's visuals sport noticeably smoother edges, along with a warmer color palette that makes everything look slightly more realistic. If you're looking to compare Accomplishments with your Achievement-hoarding friends, though, forget it - GTA IV ignores these half-assed consolation prizes altogether. PS3 owners also have to put up with a nearly eight-minute installation the first time they start the game, which puts the normally slower Blu-ray load times on par with the Xbox 360 version. (That is, unless it's running on a 360 with no hard drive, which we're told will face much longer loads.)


GameTrailers.com (9.8)

While GT usually puts up head-to-head videos, the official video review is only for the 360 version. They have yet to play the PS3 version.

They do mention a few techical hitches here and there (with framerate), but since they can't compare it to the PS3 version, there's no way of knowing if that's for both versions in this case.


Game Reactor (Sweden)

While I don't understand the language, here's what Forsete says it translates to (and if anyone can confirm this, that'd be awesome):


Originally Posted by Forsete:
Swedish Gamereactor mentioned in their 10/10 review that they were pretty surprised regarding the difference between the PS3 and 360-versions. The PS3-version features better colours, contrast, load times and what looks to be better resolution textures. The game also looks sharper and has a more stable fps.


Gamespy UK


Quote:
Although it's got a few problems that pop up from time to time, Grand Theft Auto IV is still an absolutely gorgeous game. Like the previous games in the series, it suffers from some texture pop-in and draw distance issues, although these should in no way affect your enjoyment of the game. It's easy to just consider those technical flaws the price you've got to pay for admission to the most impressive game world ever created. There's so much going on that you'll only really notice the flaws if you look for them, and if you're doing that there's a good chance you're missing out on something spectacular. The overall art design and visual aesthetics are extremely pleasing to the eye, and they aren't hurt by the technical issues.

For those who have to decide between the Xbox 360 and PS3 versions, we should mention that these flaws are slightly less noticeable in the PS3 game. There are a few other minor differences as well, the biggest being the PS3 game's Sixaxis controls. You can use the controller's tilt feature to perform wheelies on motorbikes or control your helicopter, but it just ends up feeling forced. You're much better off just turning them off and sticking with the default control scheme. The Xbox 360 version, on the other hand, has Achievements and features a more intuitive controller (though that may just be this reviewer's personal opinion). Both versions are excellent, so you really can't go wrong

占个位置........焦急等待GTA中......:aeth

看贴不回贴会变猪的~支持PS3，问下，蓝光的容量那么大，怎么和360版本的画面差不多啊~:aeth

[quote]原帖由 [i]plum0506[/i] 于 2008-4-28 17:52 发表 [url=http://www.ps3ol.com/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=267486&ptid=32796][img]http://www.ps3ol.com/images/common/back.gif[/img][/url]
看贴不回贴会变猪的~支持PS3，问下，蓝光的容量那么大，怎么和360版本的画面差不多啊~:aeth [/quote]

画面好坏和容量没关系，容量大当然可以使用更精细的材质帖图。
但是游戏商不会考虑一个游戏做2遍，那样成本会很高。为了照顾360的D9容量，所以PS3大容量可以说被浪费了。
简单的说PS3被360拖了后腿。

[[i] 本帖最后由 joyhhh 于 2008-4-28 17:57 编辑 [/i]]

"PS3的抗锯齿略为优秀，比360版更加圆润光滑"
其它网站都不是这么说的:yun

蓝光被浪费了啊，50G的容量装了个4.7G。。。

[quote]原帖由 [i]intrace[/i] 于 2008-4-28 18:21 发表 [url=http://www.ps3ol.com/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=267513&ptid=32796][img]http://www.ps3ol.com/images/common/back.gif[/img][/url]
"PS3的抗锯齿略为优秀，比360版更加圆润光滑"
其它网站都不是这么说的:yun [/quote]

除了那个kotaku的编辑，我还没看见谁说360版抗锯齿比PS3好。
那么多权威网站的测评不转，偏挑个玩语言文字的测评来转，此中奥妙不言而喻。

唉``孩子 你要记着  PS3才是王道.....:pdgjk    .............................偏激了 唉 低调低调....

哎.............................400块的盘和7块钱的盘竟然差不多...

[quote]原帖由 [i]gdyslb[/i] 于 2008-4-28 19:25 发表 [url=http://www.ps3ol.com/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=267613&ptid=32796][img]http://www.ps3ol.com/images/common/back.gif[/img][/url]
哎.............................400块的盘和7块钱的盘竟然差不多... [/quote]


这是什么逻辑？老外的测评不是给玩7块钱的盘看的。
再说玩7块钱的盘，你能联网吗？怎么叫差不多？

楼主辛苦了~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

先观望一下，大家入了再说

10楼说得好。一针见血。

啥新闻嘛... 连游戏名称一下都没提到.

game of the year? 不会吧

明天！！就在明天！！！

我要去排队！！！:ohgc

我的盘明天才到阿   急死了

人生中最漫长的 一天

至于评价 我完全无视了  无论说好的 和说不好的       因为GTA4已经完全超出了几个杂志能评测的范围i和高度，  所以 GTA4  MGS FF13这样的游戏评测已经没有太大意义。。。

支持ps3!!!!!!

再等一天。。。再等一天有可以了

360机器太滥，老型号机器故障率达到90%！

finally got my GTA4 today~